My two Boston's went hog wild for these toys, and they get super excited to play fetch and tug with us and each other for these toys.They are heavy chewers especially on rope toys, and though I tried to space out giving them only a couple at a time, all the toys are pretty shredded. We've had to cut off long loose strings but they still play with them.My dog Ash, a 50 pound lab mix, would seemingly spend forever rolling this toy around until all of the food was out of it. We periodically put part of his meal in his bowl and the rest of it in the toy to both entertain and enrich him. What I like best is that it keeps Ash busy without a lot of participation from me. The ability to change the size of the dispensing hole is helpful for different kinds of treats/food we put in there. Ash likes to keep it on a rug where there's more friction - but if it rolls onto the hardwood floor, he picks it up with his mouth and carries it back to the rug which is very cute to watch.My young border collie is delighted with the rope toys. There are enough toys that the selection will last for a while, even under aggressive chewing and tugging. So many rope toys are large for her mouth [she weighs 35#] and these are made from rope with a smaller diameter. And several of the tugs have a loop for me to use when we play. All the toys are made of rope which is nice; no squeakers to tear out. Many of the reviews talk about plastic, but I ordered the all rope set: no treat ball or other plastic toys. Will order another set to replace these when they wear out.I have a 3 month old, 9lb hound mix who chews on absolutely everything. I’ve been giving him these for about 4 days and he loves them. His baby teeth haven’t done much damage yet and they provide a great distraction. Took off stars because the package was incomplete and missing one toy.I think this would be a good product for a different dog. Mine likes to chew on harder plastic but these were all rubber (I couldn't tell from the picture) and he has no interest in them. There were a lot of toys and I'm sure they would keep other puppies very happy.Our 7 month old small puppy loves these. She’s a 13 lb. mix breed. These are a decent price for all you get, it helped her when teething & she likes playing tug of war with them.My dog loves this...he pushes it towards me every night for "fun time". The only problem is...make sure to screw the top on all the way because the FIRST day....he learned how to unscrew the top!These are definitely not for puppies. Pictureattached. The red rope used to be attached to the blue tire. It only took a few hours before I was picking blue pieces up of the floor. The blur rope had a ball on one end; he chewed right through the rope. He got a piece of the pink football in about 15 minutes. Don't spend the money if you have an aggressive char or a puppy.